The exterior of First + Broad Pizza Company during sunset, featuring outdoor seating with picnic tables, potted plants, umbrellas, and illuminated windows and signs.

Discover our Small Town Famous Pizza Joint

Place Online Order

Local Favorites

Five pizzas with different toppings on metal trays and a wooden cutting board, including pepperoni, sausage, vegetables, and cheese.

Small $9.82 / Large $18.62

SHADY GRADY PIZZA

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, and fresh mushrooms

Small $9.82 / Large $18.62

Small $11.37 / Large $21.99

BIG POPPA

Pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon, & ham

Small $11.37 / Large $21.99

Small $14.48 / Large $26.90

THE KAREN

Ricotta, pesto, olives, mushrooms, onions, artichokes, feta, spinach, tomatoes, and balsamic glaze

Small $14.48 / Large $26.90

$10.34

SMASH BURGER COMBO

Fresh 100% Black Angus beef topped with melted cheese and grilled onions, served with a side of fries.

$10.34

$11.37

PHILLY CHEESE STEAK SANDWICH

Steak, peppers, onions, and mozzarella

$11.37

$12.41

TRUE ITALIAN SANDWICH

Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, spring mix, tomatoes, mayo, spicy mustard, and Italian dressing

$12.41

HIGH FALUTIN SALAD

Goat cheese, strawberries, oranges, pecans, craisins, and fried chicken breast

$12.41

Black and white line drawing of a slice of pizza with cheese and various toppings.

Our Full Menu

Appetizers

$7.23

GARLIC KNOTS

$7.23

$8.27

GARLIC KNOTS W/CHEESE

$8.27

$12.41

ONION RINGS

$12.41

FRIED MUSHROOMS

$12.41

$9.82

FRIED MOZZ STICKS

$9.82

$11.37

FRIED HOUSE CHIPS

Crispy fried chips, blue cheese crumbs and hot sauce

$11.37

$12.41

DOODLE CHIPS

Fried house chips topped with ranch, mozzarella cheese & bacon

$12.41

$10.35

BRIAN'S FRIED PICKLES

(Named after Brian Hayes)

$10.35

$11.37

BRUSCHETTA

$11.37

MONICA'S CHA CHA BOARD

(Named after Monica Thompson) Variety of meats, cheeses, & fruits

$11.37

$14.49

FRIED/BAKED WINGS (1LB)

$14.49

$27.95

FRIED/BAKED WINGS (2LB)

$27.95

$40.40

FRIED/BAKED WINGS (3LB)

$40.40

$14.49

BONELESS WINGS (1LB)

$14.49

$27.95

BONELESS WINGS (2LB)

$27.95

$40.40

BONELESS WINGS (3LB)

$40.40

$10.34

FRIED RAVIOLI

$10.34

$12.41

BOONE'S FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

(Named Boone Prince) Topped with goat cheese & balsamic glaze

$12.41

$5.16

CARROTS & CELERY STICKS

$5.16

$12.41

CHILLI CHEESE FRIES

$12.41

$4.14

FRIES

$4.14

$12.41

LOADED FRIES

Fries topped with ranch, bacon, and cheese

$12.41

$6.21

TOMATO BASIL SOUP CUP

$6.21

$10.34

5 MEATBALLS NO BREAD

Meatballs, mozzarella cheese, sauce

$10.34

Pastas

$9.93

SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

$9.93

$11.37

CHICKEN PARM

$11.37

$13.99

LASAGNA

$13.99

$13.44

BAKED ZITI

$13.44

Salads

$11.37

SLEAZY CAPRESE

Fresh sliced mozzarella and Roma tomatoes with balsamic vinegar glaze

$11.37

$9.30

THE POPEYE SALAD

Fresh spinach, mushrooms, Roma tomatoes, bacon & feta cheese

$9.30

THE BALBOA

Fresh romaine/Arcadian spring mix, red onions, Roma tomatoes, green peppers, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni & black olives

$9.30

$9.30 / $5.68

THE GREEK

Fresh romaine lettuce, red onions, black olives, Roma tomatoes, feta cheese, pepperoncini peppers & Greek dressing

$9.30 / $5.68

JULIUS CAESAR

Fresh romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese, croutons & Caesar dressing

$9.30 / $5.68

$11.37

THE WO WO

(Named After Carolyn Rinker Wynn) Lettuce, cheese, tomatoes, onions, bacon, ham, turkey & croutons

$11.37

Pizza

$11.37 / $21.99

BIG PAPA

“I Love it When You Call Me” – mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sliced sausage, ground beef, bacon & ham

$11.37 / $21.99

$9.82 / $18.62

SHADY GRADY

Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni & fresh mushrooms

$9.82 / $18.62

$8.27 / $15.51

BIG CHEESE

Lots of mozzarella cheese

$8.27 / $15.51

$13.44 / $25.86

WHITE CHICK

Ricotta cheese/pesto sauce, mozzarella cheese, sliced Roma tomatoes, fresh spinach & grilled chicken

$13.44 / $25.86

HOT CHICK

Ricotta cheese/pesto sauce, tomatoes, spinach & buffalo chicken

$13.44 / $25.86

$9.30 / $17.58

MAUI WOWIE

Mozzarella cheese, ham & pineapple

$9.30 / $17.58

$12.41 / $23.79

DEVIL IN A BLUE DRESS

Blue cheese, buffalo chicken & spinach

$12.41 / $23.79

$11.89 / $22.76

HAWTHORNE'S CHICKEN BACON RANCH

(Named after Tylar Hawthorne)

$11.89 / $22.76

$10.86 / $20.69

POPEYE PIZZA

Spinach, mushroom, bacon, feta cheese & tomatoes

$10.86 / $20.69

$11.37 / $22.76

ALL THAT!

All meats & vegetable toppings (does not include chicken)

$11.37 / $22.76

$9.30 / $17.58

BIG DILL

Ranch, pickles & Italian seasoning

$9.30 / $17.58

$14.48 / $26.90

THE KAREN

(Extra like Karen) Ricotta cheese/pesto sauce, olives, mushrooms, onions, artichokes, feta cheese, spinach, tomatoes with a balsamic glaze

$14.48 / $26.90

$11.89 / $22.76

KEEPING UP WITH THE JONESES

Mozzarella cheese topped with Jones Country Meats jalapeño cheddar sausage

$11.89 / $22.76

$11.49 / $22.20

THE GOAT

Ricotta goat cheese, chicken, tomato, spinach, basil, Italian seasoning & balsamic glaze

$11.49 / $22.20

$10.86 / $20.69

BBQ CHICKEN

BBQ sauce, chicken, mozzarella cheese & red onions

$10.86 / $20.69

$13.44 / $26.90

THE MASON

(Named after Mason of course) Ranch & buffalo sauce base, grilled chicken, bacon & jalapeño mango sauce

$13.44 / $26.90

$9.82 / $19.65

MARGARITA

Mozzarella & basil

$9.82 / $19.65

$8.79 / $16.55

PEP & CHEESE

$8.79 / $16.55

$10.34 / $19.65

SUPREME

Mozzarella, beef, pepperoni, olives, onions & bell peppers

$10.34 / $19.65

$10.65 / $19.24

VEG OUT

Mozzarella, mushrooms, red onion, tomato, green peppers, jalapeños, olives & pepperoncini

$10.65 / $19.24

ANY WAY YOU SLICE IT

Not hungry for a full pizza? Order a slice of your favorite instead.

$4.35

Pepperoni slice

$4.35

$4.04

Cheese slice

$4.04

$5.28

CREATE YOUR OWN

$5.28

CALZONE

Ricotta Cheese + Pepperoni (add topping for additional charge)

$9.32

Regular

(Add toppings for additional charge)

$9.32

$14.49

Large

Add toppings for additional charge

$14.49

Sandwiches

All sandwiches served with chips and pickle

$12.41

TRUE ITALIAN

Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, spring mix, Roma tomatoes, mayo & spicy mustard

$12.41

WHOLE CLUB HOUSE

Sliced ham, turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, Roma tomatoes, mayo, spicy mustard & served on 3 pieces of bread

$12.41

THE BALLER

Giant meatballs covered in pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese served on a hoagie roll

$12.41

CHICKEN PARM SUB

Chicken, pizza sauce & cheese served on a hoagie roll

$12.41

$4.14

GRILLED CHEESE

$4.14

$10.35

GRILLED CHEESE WITH SOUP

$10.35

$10.34

BLT

Sliced bread, mayo, bacon, spring mix, & tomato

$10.34

$12.41

CUBAN

Hoagie, pork, pickles, spicy mustard, ham & cheese

$12.41

BURGERS AND DOGS

$10.34

SINGLE BURGER COMBO

Fresh Angus Beef topped w/ grilled onion & cheese

$10.34

$11.84

DOUBLE BURGER COMBO

Two Fresh Angus Beef patties topped w/ grilled onion & cheese

$11.84

$14.48

TRIPLE BURGER COMBO

Three Fresh Angus Beef patties topped w/ grilled onion & cheese

$14.48

$9.99

FOOTLONG DOG

100% Black Angus Beef foot long Hot Dog (add chili for additional charge)

$9.99

$7.75

JONES SMOKED DOG

Jones Country Meat Smoked Sausage

$7.75

Sweet Treats

$4.13

Brownies

$4.13

$2.99

Large Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.99

$4.13

Hersey Icecream

One scope of Hersey Icecream

$4.13

Black and white artistic illustration of a citrus fruit cross-section, resembling a lemon or lime, with detailed internal segments.

Line drawing of a sandwich with bread, lettuce, and slices of meat or cheese.

Three silver decorative leaves with intricate vein patterns on a black background.

Weekly Events

Mondays

Four open cardboard boxes filled with cooked chicken wings on a table.

BOGO Wings

DINE IN ONLY | Starts at 5:00 PM

Tuesdays

Black cornhole game board for First & Broad Pizza Company with a slice of pizza illustration. Cornhole bags in blue with white stars and red with white stripes are placed on the board.

Cornhole Tournament

Entry Time: 6 PM   |  Start Time: 7 PM

Thursdays

Man performing music on stage, playing an acoustic guitar.

Live Music

Time: 6:30 PM - 9:30 PM

WHO WE ARE

From being the working train depot built in 1905 by the Atlantic Coast Line to currently our little pizza joint. We strive to keep both the original charm of the building while adding some fun and funky flare.

We pride ourselves of giving a little wink to the “good ole days”.

About

Private Event Room

Interested in hosting your next event at First & Broad? Contact us for booking details.

More Info

Keep up with us on social

Social